Pros & Cons of Decanting: Decanting 101

By:

Liz

spices in decanters

To decant or not to decant...

Nearly every time we organize a kitchen or pantry, the conversation comes up about decanting things like baking, dry goods, spices, cereal, etc. There are definitely pros and cons so read on to see what the professional think!

Pros of Decanting

Decanting 101:

There are many great reasons to decant but not all the things really need it – it all depends on your needs, your lifestyle, and your willingness and interest in maintaining. The look is what most people go for which is why we’ll post some of our fave products below!

The good part...

We honestly love decanting for so many reasons, not just because it makes your space look fabulous with the consistency of the canisters & labels but also keeping products fresh and easy to see. 

Creating zones in your storage spaces is key to organization and by decanting – you are creating clearly delineated groups of like items which makes keeping things tidy so much easier.

decanted jars: pros and cons of decanting
Spices in decanters on shelf in pantry
pantry full of decanters

The decanting upkeep...

There's some work involved:

Keeping up with the decanting process can be challenging for some people. It’s not super difficult but it does take some planning, time and attention. Things like spices need refreshing much less frequently than cereal or baking might which is why sometimes we decant certain categories rather than all the things.

Pro tip: if you have kids, we typically recommend BPA free plastic rather than glass for safety

What are the cons of decanters?

  • if you identify your items by the color or style of the bag or can, decanting can make this a challenge 
  • the upkeep can be daunting for high turnover products
  • remembering to check your back stock before buying new sometimes throws people off (we always set up a back stock/refill zone for decanted items)

Pro tip: when replenishing any canister, empty the older contents into a bowl, fill with the new (wash & dry if needed first), then add the old on top. This way you don’t end up with a bunch of stale stuff at the bottom!

Choosing the right containers for Decanting

How to pick the right decanter?

spices in decanters
Oxo Pop
OXO Pop canisters
Neat canisters
Neat canisters
Neat spice jars
Neat spice jars
Marie Kondo canisters
Marie Kondo canisters
THE canisters
THE canisters
oxo pop canisters
OXO Pop cereal dispenser
French square glass
French square glass

Decanting or not?

It’s a matter of personal preference so if it calls to you, go for it! Check out our favorite products to help you make the decision – and use the info above to see if it makes sense for your and your lifestyle!

More Posts

Is finally getting your home organized a resolution for 2025?

Consider this your invite to make it happen!

We can tackle any space in your home including:

  • kitchen & pantry
  • closets
  • storage spaces (i.e. attic or basement)
  • garage
  • Kids’ rooms & playrooms
  • office
  • and more…. there’s not much we can’t do!


Imagine perfectly organized spaces that bring you joy and peace of mind with a stress-free process working with our highly experienced team that treats you and your home with care and compassion.